Did the Splinterlands Rental Market or Owning Cards Survive Better?
The rental market in Splinterlands survived better than outright card ownership for most players. Renting allowed participants to exit quickly when earnings dropped, while owners were left holding assets that lost value as the play-to-earn model contracted. This conclusion holds for the period following the game's peak in 2021-2022, when token prices collapsed and player numbers fell.
Why renting seemed attractive at first
When Splinterlands launched its play-to-earn mechanics, owning cards was the standard entry point. Players bought card packs or individual cards on the secondary market, then used those cards to battle and earn SPS governance tokens and DEC reward tokens. The rental market emerged as a way for owners to earn passive income by lending out their cards to other players.
Renters paid a daily fee in DEC to borrow cards. This let them access high-level cards without the upfront purchase cost. For a player with limited capital, renting a competitive deck for a few days cost far less than buying the same cards outright.
What changed when token prices crashed
The collapse of Splinterlands' play-to-earn model followed a pattern common in crypto gaming. DEC and SPS tokens lost most of their value. The reward pool shrank as the player base contracted. This had different effects on owners versus renters.
Owners faced:
- Depreciating assets: Card prices on the secondary market dropped. A card bought for $50 might sell for $5 or less.
- Illiquidity: Even at lower prices, many cards took weeks or months to sell. The market had few buyers.
- Fixed costs: Owners still paid transaction fees and DEC to rent out their cards, but rental income fell as demand declined.
- No exit strategy: Selling at a loss was often the only option, and the loss could be total for cards that became worthless.
Renters faced:
- No capital loss: The renter's only cost was the rental fee. When the game became unprofitable, they simply stopped renting.
- Ability to test the game: Renters could try different strategies without committing money to a permanent purchase.
- Quick exit: Stopping rentals required a single transaction. No need to sell assets in a falling market.
The rental market's self-correcting mechanism
The rental market had a built-in safety valve that ownership lacked. When rental demand dropped, rental prices fell. Owners who wanted any income had to lower their asking rates. This made renting cheaper for the remaining players, which kept some activity alive.
Owners, however, could not lower their purchase price after buying. If you bought a card for 100 DEC and it fell to 10 DEC on the market, your loss was locked in unless you held indefinitely and hoped for a recovery that never came.
Exceptions: when ownership won
Owning cards did work better in a few specific scenarios:
- Top-tier cards: Rare legendary cards with unique abilities maintained value longer because few copies existed. Owners of these cards could still rent them at decent rates.
- Long-term collection value: Some players treated cards as collectibles rather than income generators. For them, owning was fine because they never planned to sell.
- Staking and governance: Owning cards gave access to SPS staking rewards and voting rights. Renters received none of these benefits.
The numbers tell the story
By late 2024, the daily active player count for Splinterlands had dropped roughly 90% from its 2022 peak. Card rental volumes fell similarly, but the rental market continued to function at low levels. The secondary market for card purchases became nearly dormant. Many cards had no bids at any price.
Splinterlands itself adapted by shifting toward a more traditional free-to-play model with optional card ownership. This reduced the incentive to rent or own for profit. The game still runs, but the play-to-earn component that drove both markets is effectively dead.
What this means for future crypto games
The Splinterlands experience shows that rental markets offer better survival for participants in play-to-earn games because they:
- Decouple player activity from asset speculation: You can play without betting on token prices.
- Enable rapid exit: When the model breaks, renters leave immediately. Owners are trapped.
- Self-correct pricing: Rental rates adjust to match falling demand. Purchase prices do not.
The lesson is not that renting is always better, but that asset ownership in play-to-earn games carries speculative risk that renting avoids. In Splinterlands, the rental market survived by becoming smaller and cheaper. The card ownership market survived only for those who accepted the loss and held on for reasons other than profit.
Not financial advice. whoisebert.xyz publishes market data and general information about digital assets. Crypto assets are volatile and you can lose everything you put in. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold, and we make no price predictions.
Prices are sourced from third parties and may be delayed or wrong. Verify anything you intend to act on against a primary source.